All posts

What AI Reads Before It Recommends A Lincoln Or Omaha Business

We asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Google for the best plumbers, roofers and dentists in Lincoln and Omaha, and most answers came from directory and review sites.

Topic
SEO
Published
Reading time
3 minutes
Written by
The AHXE Labs team

Summarize with AI

On Nov 18 we typed 20 questions into ChatGPT, Gemini and Google. The kind a homeowner types at 9pm with a leak under the sink: "best plumber in Lincoln NE", "best roofing company in Omaha NE", "best dentist in Lincoln NE".

Then we looked at where each answer came from.

What We Asked

10 trades, 2 cities, 3 engines, 60 checks:

  • Trades: plumber, roofing company, HVAC company, electrician, house cleaning service, landscaping company, dentist, chiropractor, auto repair shop, family law attorney.
  • Cities: Lincoln NE and Omaha NE.
  • Engines: ChatGPT and Gemini (their regular websites, with web search on) and Google AI Overviews.

We got 44 answers. 36 of them listed sources: 179 citations from 111 different websites.

Where The Answers Came From

Fig. 01

The most-cited sources in 36 AI answers, November 18, 2026

  • Gemini
  • ChatGPT
  • AngiAngi: 10 of 36 answers (Gemini 10)
  • ServiceAgent.ai's directoryServiceAgent.ai's directory: 9 of 36 answers (Gemini 8, ChatGPT 1)
  • RedditReddit: 8 of 36 answers (Gemini 8)
  • Expertise.comExpertise.com: 7 of 36 answers (ChatGPT 7)
  • ThumbtackThumbtack: 7 of 36 answers (Gemini 6, ChatGPT 1)
  • ConsumerAffairsConsumerAffairs: 5 of 36 answers (Gemini 3, ChatGPT 2)
  • BBBBBB: 4 of 36 answers (Gemini 4)
  • AvvoAvvo: 4 of 36 answers (Gemini 2, ChatGPT 2)
Answers out of 36 that cited each site, split by the engine that cited it. Google AI Overviews answered 4 of the 20 searches and cited none of these 8. 20 questions about Lincoln and Omaha businesses, asked through OpenSEO on November 18, 2026.

55% of all citations went to directories, review sites and ranking pages. 36% went to the businesses' own websites.

ChatGPT cited Expertise.com in 7 of its 13 sourced answers, and only 5 of those 13 cited a business's own site. Gemini cited the most sources, mixing Angi, Thumbtack and Reddit threads with local businesses' websites.

Some trades had their own go-to sites: Avvo and Super Lawyers for family law, Zocdoc and Opencare for dentists, Carfax for auto repair.

The second most-cited source was a software company. ServiceAgent.ai sells AI software to home service businesses, and its directory pages ("Plumbing in Lincoln, Nebraska: 15 Top Pros Ranked") showed up in 9 answers (we didn't expect that one).

One Answer Up Close

Gemini's answer to "best plumber in Lincoln NE" cited 7 sources: Angi, the ServiceAgent.ai directory (twice), Thumbtack, BBB, Yellow Pages and a water heater brand's contractor finder. None of the 7 was a plumber's own website.

It leaned on Google review counts. Its first pick came with "a 4.8-star average across over 860 Google reviews", a number it pulled through the directory pages.

What This Means If You Own The Business

The website still matters (it was cited in 24 of 36 answers). It's one of several places the AI checks.

  • Keep your Google Business Profile complete and your reviews coming in. Review counts were the number the answers quoted most.
  • Claim your listings on the sites AI reads for your trade: Angi, Thumbtack, BBB and Yelp for home services, Avvo for lawyers, Zocdoc or Opencare for dentists, Carfax for auto repair. Check that the name, phone and services match your website.
  • Make your own site easy to quote. Say what you do, where you work and what customers say in plain sentences on the page. The answers we read often reused a source's own sentence almost word for word.
  • Once a month, type the question a customer would into ChatGPT and Gemini and read the sources they list. If your company isn't in the answer, those sources are where to get listed next.

Protocol, our sister company, sets up and runs Google Business Profiles.

See Protocol

How We Did It

  • Questions went in on Nov 18 2026 through OpenSEO's AI visibility tracker: 1 answer per question per engine, United States, English.
  • AI answers change between runs and between people. This is a 1-day snapshot of 20 questions.
  • We sorted every cited website by hand into directories, review and ranking sites, local businesses' own websites, Reddit, and Google or Facebook pages.
  • For comparison, BrightLocal's national study (Sep 2026, about 200,000 local AI searches) found business websites made up 42% of citations and Google Business Profiles 28.6%. It asked different questions across more engines, so the numbers don't line up 1 to 1. Our "best [trade] in [city]" questions leaned much harder on directories.
Read BrightLocal's study

Reporters and researchers can have the full answers and source list. Email [email protected].

Gemini's top plumber in Lincoln came with over 860 Google reviews attached, and Gemini read that number on someone else's website.

Written by the AHXE LABS team

More Insights

View all posts